Chapter 16 – What Makes a Good Mentor?
THE STAFFORD KNOT | BREEDER EDUCATION SERIES
From One Breeder to Another
Sharing what we’ve learned without expecting everyone to follow in our footsteps.
When I think back over my years in dogs, I realize how much of what I’ve learned came from people who were willing to share their experience with me. Some were established breeders whose knowledge had been built over generations, while others simply had a particular skill, an understanding of a family of dogs, or an experience that helped me look at something differently. Not all of those relationships were formal mentorships, and some involved little more than a conversation at a dog show or a telephone call when I needed advice. Nevertheless, many of those conversations stayed with me, and I remain grateful for the people who took the time to have them.
I have also learned that being an experienced breeder and being a good mentor are not necessarily the same thing. Someone may have produced wonderful dogs for decades and possess an extraordinary amount of knowledge yet struggle to explain what they’ve learned or appreciate that another breeder might choose a different approach. Others may have comparatively little breeding experience but be excellent teachers in a particular subject. I don’t believe mentorship should be measured simply by the number of champions someone has produced, how long they’ve been involved, or how well known they may be within the breed. Those accomplishments can certainly reflect valuable experience, but the willingness to share knowledge thoughtfully is something different.
Over the years, I’ve come to appreciate that good mentorship isn’t about creating another breeder who does everything exactly as we do. It’s about helping someone develop the understanding and judgment necessary to make responsible decisions for themselves.
Sharing Experience Without Demanding Agreement
One of the things I value most about conversations with other breeders is hearing how they arrived at their decisions. I may not agree with a particular breeding choice, an approach to raising puppies, or an interpretation of the breed standard, but understanding the reasoning behind it often teaches me something. Occasionally, it encourages me to reconsider my own assumptions, and I think that’s a healthy part of continuing to learn.
Mentorship should allow room for those conversations. An experienced breeder can explain why a particular mating may be concerning, what they’ve observed in certain bloodlines, or how they handled a difficult situation without insisting that their solution is the only acceptable one. We can offer the benefit of our experience while acknowledging that another breeder may be working with different dogs, circumstances, resources, or objectives.
Of course, not every subject is simply a matter of personal preference. There are established principles concerning animal welfare, inherited disease, responsible husbandry, and veterinary care that deserve to be understood and respected. Good mentorship should distinguish between those responsibilities and the many decisions that involve individual judgment. I think we’re doing someone a disservice if we present our preferences as unquestionable rules, just as we would be failing them if we treated serious welfare concerns as merely another opinion.
I’ve always appreciated people who were willing to explain not only what they recommended, but why. Understanding the reasoning gives us something we can apply to situations we haven’t yet encountered. Being told to do something because a respected breeder has always done it may provide an answer for the moment, but it doesn’t necessarily teach us how to make the next decision.
Sometimes the Most Useful Thing Is a Question
When someone approaches an experienced breeder for advice, it’s natural to want to provide an immediate answer. We recognize a familiar situation, remember what worked for us, and offer a suggestion based upon that experience. Often, that is exactly what someone needs, particularly when dealing with a practical problem or something they’ve never encountered before.
But I’ve come to believe that sometimes asking a thoughtful question can be more useful than providing a solution.
When discussing a proposed breeding, for example, rather than immediately recommending a particular dog, we might ask what qualities the breeder hopes to preserve, what concerns they have about their bitch, and what they know about the families involved. Their answers may reveal that they haven’t yet considered something important, or perhaps they’ll introduce information that changes our own perspective.
The same applies to evaluating puppies, understanding health results, or making decisions about a breeding program’s future. There is considerable value in helping someone work through a question rather than simply telling them what conclusion they should reach.
That doesn’t mean leaving newer breeders to figure everything out on their own. There are times when direct advice, practical demonstrations, and immediate intervention are necessary, particularly when animal welfare or safety is involved. But where circumstances allow, encouraging someone to examine the information and consider the alternatives can help them develop confidence in their own judgment.
And I think that’s ultimately what we should hope to accomplish.
Mentorship Doesn’t Have to Mean a Lifetime Commitment
Several years ago around 2016, I developed a concept called SBT Mentor, a website intended to connect people seeking guidance with experienced Stafford breeders willing to share knowledge about particular subjects. The idea was to make mentorship more approachable by dividing it into manageable topics rather than expecting either person to enter into an open-ended relationship covering every aspect of breeding. I still own sbtmentor.help but I never developed the database again. Until I get more interest and a volunteer it will sit idle.
Someone knowledgeable about pedigrees might enjoy helping another breeder evaluate a proposed mating, while someone experienced in whelping could offer guidance on preparation or share useful educational resources. Neither would be expected to take responsibility for every future decision the other person made.
Unfortunately, the project never attracted the participation I had hoped for, and eventually I set it aside. I’ve thought about that experience from time to time, particularly as we’ve developed this Breeder Education Series.
I still believe the underlying idea has merit, but perhaps we sometimes make mentorship more complicated than it needs to be. Not everyone has the time or inclination to take on a formal mentoring relationship, and not everyone seeking advice wants or needs one. There is still considerable value in answering a question, recommending a reliable resource, sharing an experience, or offering a thoughtful perspective when someone asks.
We shouldn’t underestimate how meaningful those small contributions can be. A conversation that takes only a few minutes may help someone avoid a mistake, understand a difficult decision, or feel more comfortable asking questions in the future.
I also believe it’s reasonable for mentors to establish boundaries. Sharing knowledge doesn’t require making ourselves available at every hour, becoming involved in every disagreement, or accepting responsibility for another person’s decisions. A healthy mentoring relationship should respect the time, independence, and responsibilities of both people.
Learning Works Both Ways
One of the more rewarding things about helping another breeder is discovering that the exchange doesn’t necessarily move in only one direction. Someone who is newer to breeding may ask a question we’ve never considered, bring research to our attention, or approach a familiar problem from a different perspective. Their curiosity can encourage us to examine practices we’ve followed for years without giving them much thought.
I think experienced breeders need to remain comfortable with that possibility. Having many years behind us doesn’t mean we’ve reached a point where we have nothing left to learn, and being questioned shouldn’t automatically be interpreted as having our knowledge or experience challenged.
At the same time, I hope newer breeders recognize the value of listening to people who have spent decades working with dogs. Not everything learned through experience has been published in a journal or explained in a textbook. There are observations about particular families, subtle differences in temperament and construction, and practical lessons that can take many years to recognize.
The challenge for all of us is learning to distinguish between valuable experience, personal preference, and information supported by reliable evidence. Sometimes these things agree, and sometimes they don’t. Being willing to explore those differences respectfully can make us better breeders and better mentors.
I’ve encountered wonderful generosity in the dog world, and I’ve also experienced occasions when knowledge seemed to be treated as something to protect rather than share. I understand that people invest years of effort into developing breeding programs and may have good reasons for being selective about certain arrangements. But sharing an understanding of health, husbandry, breed history, or responsible breeding practices doesn’t diminish what someone has accomplished. I believe it adds value to those accomplishments.
What We Choose to Pass Along
As I bring this chapter of our Breeder Education Series to a close, I find myself thinking about the people who helped me during my earliest years and the things I wish I’d understood when I first began. Some lessons were learned through generous mentorship, others through my own mistakes, and quite a few through experiences I would rather not repeat. All have contributed to the way I approach breeding today.
That is really what I hoped to share through From One Breeder to Another. Not a collection of rules everyone must follow, but an opportunity to discuss the decisions and responsibilities that shape our breeding programs. We’ve explored choosing breeding stock, evaluating pedigrees and health information, raising puppies, finding suitable homes, working with other breeders, and remaining accountable for the dogs we produce throughout their lives. These are subjects that deserve thoughtful discussion, and I don’t believe any one breeder has every answer.
I also don’t believe mentorship should be about preserving our own opinions or creating people who will carry on our methods without question. The dogs, their future families, and the breeds we care about are better served when breeders understand the reasons behind their decisions and are willing to reconsider them as new information becomes available.
There is a thought I’ve returned to often throughout this educational work:
Our responsibility is not to produce people who agree with us. It is to encourage people who can think critically, question respectfully, evaluate evidence, and make informed decisions of their own.
To me, that is at the heart of good mentorship. We can share what experience has taught us, explain the mistakes we’ve made, recommend reliable resources, and offer encouragement when someone is facing a difficult decision. We can also acknowledge when we don’t know an answer or when another person may have more useful experience in a particular area.
After more than twenty years of breeding Staffords, I’m still learning, and I hope that never changes. I remain grateful to those who have shared their knowledge with me, and I hope that some of what I’ve learned may be useful to someone else along the way.
If there is one thing I would like newer breeders to take from this series, it is that they don’t have to know everything when they begin, nor should they expect to. They do, however, have a responsibility to keep learning, ask questions, and make thoughtful decisions on behalf of the dogs who depend upon them.
Perhaps the greatest contribution an experienced breeder can make isn’t producing another generation of good dogs, but helping another breeder develop the knowledge and judgment to do the same.
Questions Worth Asking Yourself
- When someone asks for my advice, am I helping them understand the reasoning behind it, or simply expecting them to follow my recommendation?
- Am I willing to share what I’ve learned, including the mistakes and disappointments, without expecting something in return?
- Can I respect another breeder’s thoughtful decision even when it differs from the one I would have made?
From One Breeder to Another is part of The Stafford Knot, Inc. 501(c)(3) Breeder Education Series, developed in collaboration with Wavemaker Staffords.